Forty years ago this week, on the evening of November 17, 1986, a Japan Air Lines Boeing 747 cargo jet was cruising over the dark, frozen interior of Alaska with a hold full of French wine. Somewhere northeast of Fort Yukon, its captain looked out the window and saw lights that, by his account, had no business being there. What followed became one of the most argued-over pilot sightings of the 20th century, and four decades later it still splits believers and skeptics right down the middle.
"Flying parallel and then suddenly approached very close"
The flight was JAL 1628, a Paris-to-Tokyo cargo run with stops in Reykjavík and Anchorage. In the cockpit were three crew members: Captain Kenju Terauchi, a 47-year-old pilot with 29 years of flying behind him, his co-pilot, and a flight engineer. Shortly after 5 p.m. local time, at about 35,000 feet, Terauchi reported lights to the left of and below the plane.
"They were flying parallel and then suddenly approached very close," he later told United Press International. He described two smaller objects and, at one point, a far larger one. He called them "the two small ships and the mother ship."
The captain radioed Anchorage air traffic control. With permission, the crew descended 4,000 feet and flew a complete 360-degree turn to see whether their company would follow. According to Terauchi, it did. "They were still following us," he said. As the jet passed near Eielson Air Force Base, outside Fairbanks, he said he glimpsed the silhouette of the big one behind them: a walnut-shaped craft with bulges above and below a wide, flat brim. "It was a very big one," he told UPI, "two times bigger than an aircraft carrier."
What the radar saw (and didn't)
This is where the story gets its staying power. FAA flight control reports indicated the object stayed with Flight 1628 for at least 32 minutes, and the controller handling the jet reported a return on his scope as close as five miles away. When the story broke at the end of December 1986, headlines announced that the sighting had been confirmed by FAA and Air Force radar.
After the jet landed safely in Anchorage, FAA investigators interviewed the crew and concluded they were "normal, professional, rational, (and had) no drug or alcohol involvement." And Terauchi kept his sense of humor. Asked why UFOs would tail a cargo plane, he joked: "We were carrying Beaujolais, a very famous wine made in France. Maybe they want to drink it." Asked whether he had been nervous: "No, I am the captain. I cannot be nervous."
But the radar picture got murkier on review. The military returns were later dismissed as clutter, and the target on the FAA's screens was judged to be most likely a coincidental split image of the 747 itself. A United Airlines jet and an Air Force C-130 in the area reported seeing nothing unusual, visually or on radar.
Jupiter, Mars, and a "UFO repeater"
The skeptics' case was led by Philip J. Klass of Aviation Week & Space Technology, who pointed out that Jupiter and Mars sat low in the sky in the direction Terauchi was looking. Jupiter was only about 10 degrees above the horizon, low enough, Klass argued, to seem level with a jet at 35,000 feet. He also noted that the pilot's later accounts didn't always match what he said on the radio that night.
The FAA's own data package added another wrinkle: it described Terauchi as a "UFO repeater" who had reported other sightings before and after November 17. One of them, in January 1987 over the same general area, was chalked up to lights from small villages diffused by thin clouds of ice crystals. Skeptical writers like Robert Sheaffer and Brian Dunning have argued that the captain, however capable, was not an unbiased observer when it came to spaceships.
The FAA man who never let it go
On the other side stands John Callahan, who in the 1980s was division chief of the FAA's Accidents, Evaluations and Investigations Division in Washington. Speaking at the National Press Club in 2007, Callahan said the voice tapes and radar data were gathered up and he briefed officials on them. By his account, at the end of that meeting one of the CIA attendees declared that the event "never happened" and that the data was being confiscated. That part is Callahan's own story, and it has never been independently confirmed, but it has made JAL 1628 a fixture of every disclosure documentary since.
Callahan himself said he first suspected a stealth military aircraft, but ended up calling the evidence inconclusive. "The FAA has procedures that cover tracking unidentified aircraft violating another's airspace," he said, "but it has no procedures for UFOs."
Why it still matters
Forty years on, Alaska's skies are back in the UFO headlines with the "jellyfish" video filmed near Anchorage, and the same old questions are back with it: what did the witnesses actually see, what did the instruments really record, and who gets to decide? JAL 1628 is a reminder that even a calm, sober, professional crew and a radar blip don't automatically add up to an answer. Was it planets on the horizon, a radar glitch, and a pilot primed to see ships? Or something that a cargo jet full of Beaujolais happened to cross paths with over the Yukon? Pour yourself a glass and decide for yourself.
Sources: UPI Archives, "A veteran pilot whose UFO sighting was confirmed on..." (Dec. 31, 1986); Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, "Close encounter over Interior Alaska draws coverage on UFO show" (2011); Wikipedia, "Japan Air Lines Cargo Flight 1628 incident" (citing the AP, The New York Times, and Skeptical Inquirer).
